Saturday, October 01, 2011

Consensus start/sit list for Week 4

Greetings, happy October. Here's your consensus start/sit list, culled from all of the start/sit links that I provided throughout the week. These are the players that had the most start or sit votes and they're listed in no particular order. Good luck this week!

QB
Start: Eli Manning, Jason Campbell, Kyle Orton
Sit: Joe Flacco, Tony Romo, Matt Hasselbeck

RB
Start: Tim Hightower, James Starks, Cedric Benson
Sit: Jahvid Best, Shonn Greene, Willis McGahee, Frank Gore

WR
Start: Santonio Holmes, Percy Harvin, Lance Moore, Denarius Moore, Sidney Rice
Sit: Nate Washington, Anquan Boldin

TE
Start: Greg Olsen, Randy McMichael, Brandon Pettigrew
Sit: Dallas Clark, Dustin Keller, Fred Davis

DST
Start: Bucs, Saints, Titans
Sit: Cowboys, Steelers, Patriots, 49ers

Kicker
Start: Jason Hanson
Sit: no consensus

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

Okay, pick one WR for this week:

Mike Williams TB
Torrey Smith BAL
Danny Amendola STL
Donald Jones BUF

Anonymous said...

Anonymous,

I'd definitely go with Mike Williams of Tampa Bay.

I've got a WR quandry of my own. Start 2 WRs (non-PPR): R. Wayne (@ TAM), M. Manningham (@ ARI), P. Harvin (@ KAN), S. Rice (v ATL)?

Sara has Harvin and Rice on her consensus start list (a feature that I love, BTW). Wayne and Manningham have been inconsistent and injured, respectively, but have higher upsides.

Decisions, decisions...

Noah
Jersey City

Anonymous said...

Thanks, I'm still leaning toward Torrey Smith. Williams hasn't been great thus far, and with Boldin on Revis Island, I could see Smith get some big targets... but obviously, I'm still questioning the move.

I like Rice and Manningham personally. I'm not convinced of the QB situation in Minnesota.

Perplexed said...

If it were me, I'd go with Harvin and Manningham. Chiefs and Cardinals secondaries stink. Answering the other question, I say Williams. Rex Ryan has said he's game planning for Smith.

Here is a question for my flex spot in a standard scoring, non PPR league:

Shonne Greene, Ben Tate, Robert Meachem, or Stevan Ridley?

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the advice Anonymous and Perplexed. I think I'm gonna go the lousy secondary route and play Manningham and Harvin.

As for Perplexed's flex decision, I'd go with Meachem, who has a TD in every game so far.

I usually prefer RBs in the flex slot, if possible. But Sara listed Greene as a consensus sit, Foster was named the starter ahead of Tate, and is Ridley really trustworthy after just six good carries in one game?

Happy Football Sunday!

Noah
Jersey City

Anthony said...

Hey FFLibrarian I would like to say that I like your blog and your advice. I also have some of the same players on my start em sit this week Such as Jason Campbell, Hightower and Starks on my Starts and Flacco Hasselbeck on my sits.
Anthony
anthonyaltamura.wordpress.com

Benjamin Hubbert said...

Hightower is killing me! Please don't tell me Ryan Torain is coming in to spoil my season. I should never draft a RB that plays for Shanahan. Rookie mistake.

Ryan M said...

I, like all the experts, sat Gore. Fox's early reports was that he was inactive...apparently no one told Gore he wasn't supposed to do well!!!